Sunday, June 21, 2009

Europeans Set To Blame Georgia For Last Year's War

According to documents obtained by Germany's Der Spiegel magazine, the European Union is ready to slam Georgia for starting last August's war with Russia over the breakaway region, South Ossetia.

While it's clear there was a war in South Ossetia, how that war started has been anything but. Almost as soon as the fighting began, Georgia's President Mikhail Saakashvili launched a PR campaign, pushing the story that Russian troops poured into the disputed region on August 7th, quickly overwhelming small Georgian force stationed there. Russia, meanwhile, said that it was the Georgian side who invaded South Ossetia first after bombarding the South Ossetian capital, Tskhinvali during the night of August 7th/8th, killing some Russian peacekeepers in the process, and that Russian troops only went in to keep their peacekeeping forces from being wiped out.

Western governments quickly embraced the Saakashvili version of events (anyone remember Senator, and at the time presidential candidate, John McCain's declaration that "we're all Georgians now" after the fighting started?), but the EU investigation finds they shouldn't have. The EU report will apparently largely back up Russia's version of events, finding that Saakashvili ordered the military action against South Ossetia and that the Russians only entered the territory after the Georgians began the fighting.

And while the European Union report is important, it's not the first to dispute Georgia's version of the war. Last November the New York Times published an in-depth piece based in large part on observations from officials with the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) that did not find evidence of the large-scale Russian offensive the Georgians said they were responding to, and at roughly the same time the BBC published their own in-depth analysis based on eyewitness reports from observers in Tskhinvali who said the Georgians opened fire on a sleeping city. (If at this point you're asking why would the Georgians launch such an attack, a probable reason is Saakashvili trying to make good on a campaign promise to bring the region back under Georgian control for the first time in over a decade by any means necessary).

The EU report, apparently, won't find the Russians blameless - it will cite them for responding with excessive force against Georgia – after retaking South Ossetia, Russia occupied part of Georgia temporarily and largely dismantled the Georgian military - and also for not protecting civilians in South Ossetia once they controlled the region (many ethnic Georgians were reportedly killed or driven from their homes by South Ossetian militias - as the occupying power, Russia had a responsibility to protect those civilians).
Sphere: Related Content

Russia Stung By D-Day Diss

Russia's Foreign Ministry spokesman Andrei Nesterenko said on Thursday that the leaders of Britain, France, Canada and the United States gave a "peculiar interpretation" of World War II at the recent commemorations of the D-Day landings in Normandy, France. Russia feels that the role of the Soviet Union in the victory over Nazi Germany was not adequately acknowledged at the event, part of a larger campaign the Russians have been on recently to give, in their opinion, proper credit to the Soviet Union's sacrifice in WWII. The Soviets lost an estimated 27 million troops and civilians in the fighting - the most of any nation.

Of course I have to ask what took the Foreign Ministry so long to raise their complaint, since the commemoration happened almost two weeks ago. And it's a little difficult for the Russians to say that they were singled out for insult since France's President Sarkozy neglected to invite Queen Elizabeth II to the event - not only was the Queen the only head of state from the Allies who was even alive during the war, she also served as a volunteer driver with the British military.
Sphere: Related Content

Saturday, June 20, 2009

Spring Goes Missing in Northern Canada

Apparently someone forgot to tell Mother Nature that it's suppose to be springtime in Northern Canada. According to the Winnipeg Free Press, as of June 11, the ground in Northern Manitoba was still completely covered in snow, the latest date ever measured. Residents in Churchill, Manitoba say they've never seen snow on the ground this late into the year and that some roads in the town remain blocked by snow drifts. Temperatures are nearly four degrees Celsius (that's almost eight degrees Fahrenheit) lower than normal.

The lack of spring in Northern Canada could wipeout an entire generation of migratory birds who give birth to chicks in the northern climes before heading south for winter. Scientists who study the habits of these birds say the late arrival of spring means that the birds won't be able to lay eggs until later in the year and that the chicks who hatch then won't be strong enough by fall to make the long flight south.

Scientists from National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration though say the cold temperatures are actually a sign of climate change and global warming - that as the Arctic warms in general, there will be greater fluctuations in temperatures and that sometimes this will mean colder than usual temps.

"People often confuse climate with weather, and this spring is a weather phenomenon," said an Environment Canada spokesperson to the Winnipeg Free Press.
Sphere: Related Content

WWI Vet Now World's Oldest Man

There are so few veterans of the First World War left that whenever there's news about one of them, I like to share. Today the folks at Guinness World Records announced that a WWI Vet, Britain's Henry Allingham, aged 113, is now officially the oldest person alive.

Mr. Allingham is one of only two surviving British WWI vets and is the only living participant from the Battle of Jutland, the biggest naval battle of World War I and the only time in history that large fleets of Battleships faced off against one another in direct combat.

Allingham joined the Royal Naval Air Service in 1915, a year before Jutland. Later in life he became an advocate WWI vets, encouraging everyone to remember their sacrifice in what was thought at the time to be the "war to end all wars".
Sphere: Related Content

Thursday, June 18, 2009

Twitter Revolution: More Hype Than Help?

You can’t watch or read a news story about the ongoing protests in Iran without hearing some mention of the role Twitter is playing. But is the role of the “Twittersphere” being over-hyped by the mainstream media?

Probably yes, according to Wired.com’s “Dangerroom” blog. While admitting that it’s hard to track the actual number of tweets, Nicholas Thompson author of the Dangerroom post notes that even the most prominent Iranian tweeters have between 10,000 and 30,000 followers, a lot of people to be sure, but just a fraction of the million plus who follow actor Ashton Kutcher. And an analysis of users who say they’re in or near Tehran finds posts in German, Spanish and English, but none in Farsi, odd for posters based in Iran.

Babak Rahimi, a professor at the University of California, San Diego, contacted by Dangerroom said that while Twitter is being used as an organizing tool, it’s not as important in Iran as cellphones or other social networking sites. So it does seem like Twitter’s role in the revolution is being overstated, just like it was in the first ‘Twitter Revolution’ - the protests in Moldova back in April over the results of their election.

At the time, news outlets like the New York Times gushed about the role that Twitter was supposedly playing in organizing the mass rallies in Moldova’s capital, Chisinau. But as the protests’ main organizer Natalia Morar would later admit to the BBC, Twitter was only one of a stew of new technologies – that included cellphones, social networking sites and SMS text messages – she and her compatriots used to organize their protests. In the end, Moldova’s Twitter Revolution was more light than heat – the Moldovan government cracked down on the demonstrations after a few days and the ‘revolution’ fizzled out.

So why all the attention to Twitter as a tool of revolution? Because Twitter is the latest hi-tech infatuation of the mainstream media (if Twitter was a person, CNN would qualify as a stalker). And since everyone inside the NYC-DC media bubble is now on Twitter, members of the MSM naturally assume that the entire world is busy tweeting. Sure Twitter is an important tool, but it’s real value is more likely in getting the story out of Iran than it is in organizing events in-country. Do we really think that these protests wouldn’t be happening if Twitter didn’t exist?

It’s a sign of some sloppy reporting by the American MSM of the whole Iranian affair, as is portraying what’s going on as a revolution. So far it isn’t. Protesters in the streets of Tehran aren’t calling for the overthrow of the Ayatollahs, they just want their votes counted, in their opinion, this time fairly (of course the counter-protesters in favor of President Ahmadinejad think the vote count should stand as is). Mir Hossein Mousavi is called a reformer and is certainly more moderate than Ahmadinejad, but he’s no Iranian Barack Obama, and even if he manages to overturn the election results as they stand now and takes the presidency, it won’t be a revolutionary change in Iran.

Or to paraphrase Mark Twain – reports of the Twitter Revolution have been greatly exaggerated.
Sphere: Related Content

Study Says Mekong River Dolphins Near Extinction

The World Wildlife Fund (WWF) is warning that the Mekong River's Irrawaddy Dolphin, one of the few species of dolphin that call rivers home, is in grave danger of extinction.

The WWF says that only between 76 and 64 Irrawaddy Dolphins are left in the Mekong, while in the past six years officials recorded the deaths of nearly 90 dolphins. Increasing levels of pollution seems to be the main cause of the demise of the Irrawaddy Dolphin in the Mekong.

In 2007, China's Baiji, or Yangtze River Dolphin, was declared "functionally extinct" - a search in 2006 found no Baiji in the Yangtze, and while there was a reported, but unconfirmed sighting in 2007, it was decided that there was not a large enough Baiji population remaining to keep the species going, so it was declared "functionally" extinct. Pollution and collisions with ships were blamed for the Baiji's demise.

The announcement of the Mekong River dolphin situation came alongside a report issued by a collection of local NGOs that pollution and plans for nearly a dozen hydroelectric dams along the Mekong threatened mass extinctions of many other species. The "Save the Mekong" coalition warns that the dams, if built, would devastate one of the world's richest fisheries. According to the coalition, the Mekong Basin accounts for 2% of all the fish caught annually in the world, and feeds tens of millions of people in Southeast Asia.
Sphere: Related Content

Carter Decries Gaza Situation (and cries)

Former President Jimmy Carter visited Gaza on Tuesday and slammed Israel for their treatment of the territory’s 1.5 million residents. Since their conflict with Hamas, who controls the territory last January, Israel has maintained a strict blockade on the Gaza Strip. But this has prevented many Gazans from repairing the thousands of buildings damaged or destroyed by the fighting. The Israeli blockade has been so tight that some Gazans have resorted to using mud to repair their damaged homes (mud historically has been used as a building material in the region so the idea's not all that crazy, we just don't usually think to build mud buildings in the middle of urban areas in the 21st century).

While the Washington Post said that Carter "decried" the Gaza destruction and the Israeli blockade, other media reports said that conditions on the ground moved him to tears. The former president didn't hold back in his criticism saying that the Gazans were being treated "more like animals than human beings", and that "never before in history has a large community been savaged by bombs and missiles and then deprived of the means to repair itself." Carter went on to say that the Israeli blockade has caused many Gazans to rely on smugglers, who use tunnels under the border from Egypt, to survive.

One interesting development - Carter said that Hamas' exiled leader Khaled Meshal, whom Carter met in Syria, told him that Hamas would accept a peace agreement with Israel if the Palestinians approved the measure in a referendum, and if Israel returned to its 1967 borders - leaving the West Bank and Gaza - this now puts Hamas in-line with the pan-Arab peace deal put forward by the Saudis in 2002.

Meanwhile a group of 40 humanitarian organizations, including the UN agency for Palestinian refugees (UNRWA), Oxfam International and CARE all called for Israel to lift its blockade to allow desperately needed humanitarian aid into Gaza.
Sphere: Related Content

Wednesday, June 17, 2009

BRICs and SCOs

You have to hand it to Russia, even though their economy has taken a beating in the global recession, they're still pushing forward with their efforts to emerge as a counterpoint to American power in the world.

In the past week Russia has played host to not one but two major regional summits - the meetings of the Shanghai Cooperation Organization and the BRIC Group (that's Brazil, Russia, India and China, the four fastest developing economies in the world). The subtext was clear, that the idea of a "unipolar" world, with the United States as the sole superpower, hasn't worked and needs to be replaced by a "multipolar" world, where global affairs are dominated by several powers, thus better representing the interests of humanity and preventing one powerful nation from imposing their will upon the rest of the world (at least that’s the theory). Of course Russia wants to be one of those "poles".

And both the SCO and BRIC are part of that strategy - powerful organizations where the US doesn't have a seat at the table. One common headline emerged from the dual summits - that the US dollar needs to be replaced as the world's sole reserve currency. Right now, nations tend to value their currency against the dollar (they will exchange their currency for Euros or Yen or whatever, but it’s the currency’s worth against the dollar that remains the important benchmark), many trade deals (like oil sales) are valued in dollars no matter where they occur, and for countries with failing economies buying and selling in dollars is always a safe option (see what happened in Zimbabwe as their currency became worthless last year).

But Russian President Dmitry Medvedev said that this is bad for the global economy because it makes the world too vulnerable to fluctuations in the American system - like how last fall's Wall Street credit crunch sparked a global recession. His solution, which he pushed to both the SCO and BRIC, is to have additional reserve currencies. The SCO even backed a Russian idea for a common currency for the SCO - like the European Currency Unit, the forerunner to the Euro.

This sparked some hysterical declarations, like this one from journalist Chris Hedges where he states, "the American Empire is Bankrupt". That's a bit of an overstatement (ok, more than a bit...)

The SCO and BRIC meetings are important, but you have to understand the nature of both bodies, they're not really policy-making groups, in fact this was the first BRIC summit ever. Their talk about other reserve and common currencies was, at this point, just talk. And while Russia would like both groups to become powerful international organizations, right now they're not. Competing interests between Russia and China (both look to dominate Central Asia and the other four current SCO members - Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Tajikistan and Uzbekistan) could likely keep the SCO from becoming anything more than it already is - an organization that meets to discuss security concerns (mostly terrorism related) in Asia.

But you do have to hand it to Russia for trying to shake up the geopolitical stage.
Sphere: Related Content

Omar vs. The Pirates

According to the BBC, Farah Ahmed Omar could have the worst job in the world. Why you ask? Because he's just taken the job as commander of the navy in pirate-plagued Somalia.

Somalia's incredibly shaky interim government is thinking boldly - they claim they've recruited 500 Somalis to train as sailors in the navy, even though they currently have no ships, and they pledge to stop their country from being a modern day Port Royal (the Jamaican city that was Pirate Central back in the golden days of piracy), even though they control virtually none of Somalia's coastline and are basically not welcome in the Puntland region, which is home to most of the Somali pirate bases.

But it wasn't always this way, Mr. Omar points out. Thanks to some clever playing of the US off the Soviet Union during the Cold War, Somalia once had one of the best navies in Africa, something Mr. Omar thinks could be true again with some help from the international community.

What struck me though from the BBC piece was something Mr. Omar said that echoed a claim from Abdiweli Ali Taar, commander of Puntland's ad-hoc Coast Guard, as quoted in MacLean's magazine's story "This Cabbie Hunts Pirates" from January (Ali Taar was once a Toronto cab driver, hence the title of the article) - that if the coalition of nations patrolling the waters off the Somali coast were to spend some of that money ashore, the piracy problem would likely disappear.
Sphere: Related Content

Tuesday, June 16, 2009

China Dodges Efforts at Emissions Reduction

Though it didn’t get a lot of coverage, last week marked the end of a round of talks in Bonn, Germany involving more than 180 countries all meeting to come up with a coherent plan to fight global warming. A new plan is needed since the current one, the Kyoto Protocol, expires at the end of 2012.

The new plan will force developed nations to slash their greenhouse gas emissions – by how much though still remains to be seen. But the United States has pushed to absolve China from being included in any system of caps.

My question is why?

The reason given, the reason that China itself pushes, is that it’s a developing nation and that being forced to cut their greenhouse gas emissions would have serious negative effects on their future economic growth.

The “developing nation” excuse though is hard to swallow when you consider that at last April’s G20 summit of the world’s 20 largest developed and developing economies, some observers said the meeting that really mattered was the G2 - the bilateral sessions between the United States and China since they are the two engines that drive the global economy. In fact those in the world of financial journalism have a term for us – “Chimerica” (the names of China and America squished together in case you missed that).

So it does beg the question of how can you be one of the two most important economies in the world while also claiming to be a developing nation with a fragile economy? Of course it’s a good deal for China since they get to avoid all of those expensive emission-capping technologies and schemes, but it’s a bad deal for the world, and one that also basically condemns any emissions-reduction plan to failure before it begins. China is now the number one producer of greenhouse gasses by most estimates, surpassing the United States. And while the US actually saw a slight reduction in its use of coal, the fuel that produces the most greenhouse gas, last year, China’s use increased, and will continue to increase for the foreseeable future – depending on which study you read, China opens between two and four new coal-fired power plants per week.

Meaning that as the developed nations reduce their emissions, China’s will continue to increase, erasing any overall reduction in the amount of greenhouse gas pumped into the atmosphere in the process. There are some countries, ones just starting to industrialize, to modernize, that can make the claim that adopting pollution-reduction technologies and shifting to cleaner fuels will hurt their economies and their populations to such a degree the extra pollution is worth it. But given the size and strength of their economy today, China’s not one of them. The US shouldn’t aid and abet, and the world can’t afford, their efforts to skirt meaningful emissions reduction efforts.
Sphere: Related Content