Following their sentence to two years in prison, Nadezhda Tolokonnikova, Yekaterina Samutsevich and Maria
Alyokhina - the members of the Russian punk collective Pussy Riot - have
become an international cause célèbre. And one performer eager to take up the
mantle for Pussy Riot is Madonna, who appeared on stage at her concert last
week in St. Petersburg, Russia, with the words Free Pussy Riot written on her
back.
But Madonna did something else during that show. To further
show her displeasure at the Pussy Riot verdict (not to mention Russia's tepid support for Gay Rights), Madonna also stomped on a
Russian Orthodox cross.
Let's reflect on that for a moment: Tolokonnikova,
Samutsevich and Alyokhina each received two-year year sentences for their
performance within Moscow's Christ the Savior cathedral on the grounds of
“promoting religious hatred”. Yet aside from some loud music, bad dancing and
profanity, Pussy Riot did nothing aside from make a purely political statement;
they caused no damage to the cathedral, nor did they utter anything against the
Orthodox religion, they recited their punk prayer to the Virgin Mary asking:
“Holy Mother, Blessed Mother, drive Putin out!” It certainly was not
disrespectful to anyone aside from Vladimir Putin.
On the other hand, Madonna decided to step on the symbol of the Russian Orthodox faith, which seems more like an act of “religious hatred”? And before justifying Madonna's actions as an act of free speech/free expression, let us for a moment contemplate what the reaction would be if at a concert in Tel Aviv, Madonna decided to stomp on the Star of David to protest some action by the government of Benjamin Netanyahu.
On the other hand, Madonna decided to step on the symbol of the Russian Orthodox faith, which seems more like an act of “religious hatred”? And before justifying Madonna's actions as an act of free speech/free expression, let us for a moment contemplate what the reaction would be if at a concert in Tel Aviv, Madonna decided to stomp on the Star of David to protest some action by the government of Benjamin Netanyahu.
Putin could actually use Madonna's
protest to his advantage. Everyone regards the Pussy Riot trial as an attempt
to stifle dissent in Russia by charging these women with crimes far outside of
the scope of what they actually did; it is seen as a politically-motivated
prosecution pure and simple. Putin could deflect, or attempt to deflect, these
charges by calling for the arrest of Madonna on the same grounds of promoting
religious hatred thanks to her act of outright religious vandalism.
It would be a fascinating way for
Putin to turn the tables on his critics.
1 comment:
This is a very interesting perspective, I wonder what the outcome would be.
Post a Comment