Monday, June 8, 2009

What Would George Orwell Think of Twitter?

Sixty years ago today, George Orwell’s dystopian novel 1984, the classic study of a government run amok in the name of ‘safety’, was released. If it’s been awhile since you last read 1984, it presents a barely-recognizable England where its citizens are under constant surveillance by an omnipresent government, humanized in the persona of ‘Big Brother’ the dear leader who stares at them 24/7 from video screens installed in every home, to protect them of course.

The Guardian marks the occasion with this post from Henry Porter who looks at the government’s (in this case the British government) desire for public surveillance through the lens of 1984, he draws some interesting parallels between ‘Oceania’, the nation making war against Big Brother’s homeland Ingsoc, and the threat of global terrorism today, arguing that like Oceania, global terrorism is an equally poorly-defined threat that is used to justify government intrusion into individual liberties under the banner of ‘security’.

It’s interesting to speculate what Orwell would think of the security cameras that stare at us from every grocery store, ATM and, increasingly, street corner, and what he would think of our placid acceptance of these devices in our lives (not to mention how his ultimate symbol of government impression – Big Brother himself – has been used as the conceit for a cheesy reality show).

But the article made me think of something else entirely – Twitter, the latest Internet craze, the site that allows you to tell the world about your life, in 140-character bursts. It reminds me of another concept from Orwell’s 1984 – Newspeak.

Newspeak was the Ingsoc government’s attempt to simplify language – rather than have a collection of words to describe a concept like “bad”: poor, unpleasant, dire, deficient (and about four dozen other synonyms), it was replaced by one word: “ungood”. Something very bad was “plus ungood” or “double plus ungood” if it was absolutely awful. The stated reason for Newspeak was efficiency, the real goal though was the further control of society – to so limit human ability to communicate beyond the simplest constructions, so that fomenting a rebellion against Big Brother would be impossible - people simply would not be able to express the deep concepts and emotions that motivate individuals to oppose tyranny.

And that brings me back to Twitter. Am I saying it is some sort of nefarious government mind-control plot? Of course not. But I do have to wonder if it could not have a similar effect, by limiting expression to 140 character bursts, do we run the risk of losing our ability to clearly express complex ideas? (Let’s not forget text messaging, or TXT MSGNG, which also stresses a similar economy of characters) Just last week, Senator Charles Grassley decided to use Twitter to attack the Obama Administration’s health care proposals. Unfortunately for Grassley, the truncated Twitter-speak made him sound like an idiot – few Tweets or Texts read like fine literature.

But is Twitter the right place for public discourse on a complex issue like national health care in the first place? My answer is no, yet pressure to use the new technology is driving the debate there, and forcing it to conform to the rigid standards of the new media. It makes you wonder though, if we allow the media to dictate the message, will we lose the ability to make complex arguments all together?

It’s certainly a question Orwell would have pondered.
Sphere: Related Content

Sunday, June 7, 2009

Yes, they actually have elections in Iran

The conventional wisdom on Iran - from the American perspective at least - is that it's a country run by a cabal of religious leaders and one loopy dictator, "President" Mahmoud Ahmadinejad. But Ahmadinejad was actually elected to the office and stands for re-election this week. And the traits that make the West think he's a bit nuts, might just derail his bid for a second term.

Iran is apparently abuzz over last week's televised presidential debate between Ahmadinejad and his main challenger Mir-Hossein Mousavi, a former prime minister and once-close confidant to the Islamic Republic's founder the late Ayatollah Khomeini (despite that pedigree, Mousavi is considered a moderate reformer). Ahmadinejad came out in the debate in his usual style, rhetorical guns blazing, essentially accusing Mousavi of treason and corruption, his sons of stealing from the government and his wife, a university professor, of faking her credentials (The Guardian has video highlights of the debate).

But Mousavi shot back - accusing Ahmadinejad of being a bad Muslim for making accusations against his family without offering proof, and slammed the president for ruining Iran's reputation abroad with his claims that the Holocaust never happened, along with his confrontational attitude towards the global community.

According to EurasiaNet, the debate was an eye-opener for many Iranians, since the tightly-controlled, state-run media in Iran usually shies away from showing Ahmadinejad's rants and conspiracy theories. The belligerent Ahmadinejad that appeared in the debate was not the one they were use to seeing. After the debate, watched by perhaps 60% of all Iranians, people took to the streets to talk about what they had just seen, with some impromptu political rallies breaking out.

Ahmadinejad's attack-dog approach to the debate may have backfired. Not only did it spark a surge of interest in the Iranian public, which previously had been fairly apathetic towards the election, but it also prompted some stinging rebukes from Iran's religious leadership. Ayatollah Khamenei, Iran's supreme religious leader, took Ahmadinejad to task for his unsubstantiated charges against Mousavi saying: "one doesn’t like to see a nominee, for the sake of proving himself, seeking to negate somebody else," basically putting a lid on negative campaigning in the process.

Another of Iran's religious leaders, Grand Ayatollah Yusef Saanei (himself another Khomeini disciple) went a step further and urged Iranian voters to oust President Ahmadinejad for failing to improve the lives of poor Iranians and, again, for damaging the country's image abroad by failing to live up to a 2003 deal where Iran agreed to suspend its nuclear research program and for his repeatedly calling the Holocaust a 'myth'.

It's worth remembering that Ahmadinejad was actually elected on a platform of making sure Iran's oil wealth helped out the poorest members of their society. But during his reign, little progress has been made in reducing poverty in Iran, while state resources have been diverted to the country's nuclear research program – something that, along with his own belligerence, has helped to isolate Iran from the international community.

But with Ahmadinejad taking flak from Iran's religious authorities and political reformers suddenly energized by last week's debate, Thursday's election could be one to watch.
Sphere: Related Content

Gazans Fall Victim to Tunnel Scam

As if the military campaign last January that destroyed thousands of homes and the ongoing economic blockade of their homeland by Israel don't make life hard enough in Gaza, The Guardian reports that thousands of Gazans have another problem - they've lost their life savings to scam artists.

The scam centered on the hundreds of smuggling tunnels running under the sealed Gaza/Egypt border. Because of the Israeli blockade, the tunnels have become the life-blood of the Gazan economy - just about everything is brought through them: food, building materials, luxury items and creature comforts. The amount of commerce flowing through these tunnels has made some of their operators rich, and there's the hook for the scam: that investors could turn a quick profit by helping to fund the construction of more tunnels (tunnel construction can cost upwards of $100,000).

In a land with epidemic levels of unemployment, the offers seemed too good to pass up. Problem was that these tunnels people invested in didn’t, and never would, exist; scammers took investors money and disappeared. According to officials in Gaza, the tunnel scam has already netted $100 million from duped investors, though other estimates put the loss total much higher. Meanwhile, Gaza's Hamas-led government doesn't seem to be too willing to investigate the tunnel scam because of their own involvement in the smuggling industry and because some of the lead scammers likely have ties to the organization themselves.
Sphere: Related Content

Saturday, June 6, 2009

Economy in Russia - Hunger Strikes, Putin Slams

A couple of weeks ago I posted this story about a group of Siberian stewardesses who went on a hunger strike to try and shame their now-bankrupt former employer, the airline KrasAir, into paying them up to eight months of back wages. Apparently this isn't the only work-related hunger strike going on in Russia at the moment.

Workers at the Baikal Pulp Mill are well into their own hunger strike to protest not receiving all the wages owed to them when their plant shut down last year. This week 21 former employees joined a group of 42 already on a hunger strike. In total some 2,000 former workers say they're owed 100 million rubles ($3.25 million). Actually it's a good thing the Pulp Mill closed, because for decades it dumped its waste straight into Lake Baikal, the world's deepest lake and one of its most unique ecosystems - but the workers were promised new jobs at a new facility, which like their back wages, has failed to materialize.

Another group of workers in the town of Pikalyovo (near St. Petersburg) could have resorted to a hunger strike of their own when the three major factories in their town were shut down (taking with them the town's supply of hot water as well as their jobs), but why do that when you have Prime Minister Vladimir Putin in your corner?

Putin visited Pikalyovo to check on the situation personally. But officials thought they could pull a fast one on the Prime Minister by suggesting he visit other factories in the region. According to Pravda.ru, they quickly learned that pissing off the most powerful man in Russia isn't a good idea.

Putin used his visit to Pikalyovo as an opportunity to bitch-slap the local authorities - first asking them: "why did you make everything look like a dump here?" during a tour of the shuttered factories, then asking them "why was everyone running about like cockroaches here before my arrival?" Putin sat down with the owner of Pikalyovo's main industries, Oleg Deripaska - who until the economic crisis last year was Russia's richest man. Putin ordered that the 41 million rubles in back wages be paid to the workers, the next day. He then told Deripaska to reopen the factories - when Deripaska forgot to sign a the documents authorizing the plants' restart, Putin was said to have thrown a pen at him, then demanded it back when Deripaska tried to walk away with it.

How much of this tale is true is anyone's guess, since it does sound a little too much like a propaganda piece, casting Putin as hero of the working man, but it sure makes for a great read - and seems like a great blueprint for dealing with any future Wall Street bailout requests.
Sphere: Related Content

As US media markets shrink, ethnic ones grow

By now you've read stories about how American newspapers are dying, and how even viewership among cable news channels is down, but there is one sector of the media that is seeing strong and steady growth - ethnically-themed outlets.

Publications, radio and cable TV stations aimed at specific ethnic groups in America, usually in their native language, are nothing new, but a poll released this week finds that nearly 60 million Americans - basically one in five - are regular consumers of ethnic media, a jump of 16% from a poll conducted just four years ago in 2005. The strongest growth was seen among African-American newspapers and magazines, which grew by 42% since 2005, and Spanish-language radio, which is becoming a fixture in markets - like North Carolina and Washington - places not usually noted for their large Hispanic populations.

And the number of Americans tuned into ethnic media could even be higher. The poll, released at the annual Ethnic Media Expo and Awards, was conducted only in eight languages - Cantonese, English, Hindi, Korean, Mandarin, Spanish, Tagalog, and Vietnamese, which left many ethnic groups out of the poll.

Officials at the Expo said that the poll's results should be a message to advertisers and politicians alike not to ignore this vibrant sector of the media.
Sphere: Related Content

Thursday, June 4, 2009

Update #1 - Cuban invitation

Yesterday, I wrote this post about how most members of the Organization of American States - except for the US - wanted to reverse the nearly four decades-long ban on Cuba. Well, the OAS went ahead today and did in fact vote to lift the ban.

The United States has, not surprisingly, slammed the decision, saying that Cuba's Communist system doesn't fit in with the mission of the OAS. Robert Menendez, a Democratic Senator from New Jersey and himself a Cuban-American, has gone so far as to suggest that Congress cut American funding to the OAS, which gets 60% of its budget from the US.

But all the bluster is likely for nothing since Cuba is saying that while they're happy the OAS lifted their suspension, so far they have no intention of rejoining the organization
Sphere: Related Content

Update #2 - Hope for Demoracy in Russia?

Here we go back to April to revisit the case of Anton Chumachenko, who at that time was a newly-elected member of the St. Petersburg legislative council. Like many recent elections in Russia - from last year's presidential vote to April's high-profile mayoral race in Russia's Olympic city (in 2014 that is), Sochi - Chumachenko's was also marred by accusations of vote rigging in favor of the dominant United Russia party.

This worked out well for Chumachenko since he ran on the United Party ticket. But the 23-year old Chumachenko decided that wasn't the way he wanted to start his political career, so he challenged his own victory. Now Radio Free Europe is reporting that the court ruled in Chumachenko's favor - which in this case means his election was fraudulent - and gave the seat to his primary challenger, the Yabloko Party's Boris Vishnevsky (Yabloko was one of the two main liberal parties in Russia that flourished in the 1990s and still has solid support in fairly liberal St. Petersburg).

RFE reports that while the Chumachenko case is rare, it's not unique, citing several other cases across Russia where charges of vote fraud are being investigated, or where the public is pushing for the recall of a candidate they feel won their seat improperly. Whether it is a reliable sign of some of the reforms promised by President Dmitry Medvedev taking root though remains to be seen.
Sphere: Related Content

Obama apology tour (really?)

Right now I'm watching MSNBC's rebroadcast of President Obama's speech early this morning in Egypt (click here for the full text). So far, it's an excellent, wide-ranging, but ultimately balanced speech hitting on all the hot topics in the Mid-East and wider Muslim world - Iran, Iraq, Israel/Palestine, extremism, etc.

One thing I haven't heard though is Obama apologizing for America, or America's role in the world. This has become the default charge of Obama's foreign policy critics that he is running around the world "apologizing" for America.

Frankly, that's utter nonsense (I'd prefer to use another word, but I try to keep my posts PG). Obama has been stressing the need for America to do crazy things like actually listen to and respect other nations - a break from the Bushite/Neoconservative unilateral foreign policy of "shut up and do what your told."

But to the neocons, this equals both apology and surrender, making Obama the Neville Chamberlain of our time. Case in point: this anti-Obama screed published by Nile Gardiner on Tuesday. Nile is the Director of the Margaret Thatcher Center for Freedom at the Heritage Foundation.

I don't care if Gardiner, the Heritage Foundation and London's Telegraph newspaper want to slam Pres. Obama, they just shouldn't offer up such intellectually lazy arguments as the one Nile puts forward (really, if you have a title like Director of the Margaret Thatcher Center for Freedom you should be able to put together a decent argument). Just three paragraphs into his screed, Nile says this: "the Obama doctrine is now lying in tatters after North Korean tyrant Kim Jong-Il and Iranian demagogue Mahmoud Ahmadinejad met Obama’s recent overtures with missile tests and even a nuclear blast from Pyongyang." The implication being that this wouldn't have happened on George Dubya's watch.

But, in fact, it did. North Korea's first nuclear test happened in 2006, six years into the reign of Bush II; Iran's ballistic missile program also progressed by leaps and bounds during the Bush regime, so has (if we believe the most dire estimates) Iran's nuclear program.

These regimes weren't slowed by the Bush's unilateral foreign policy - it could be argued (successfully I think) that the belligerent tone and lack of diplomatic engagement actually encouraged their weapons programs, making the world not more safe, but less. Just as Bush's policy of "my way or the highway" damaged our relations with wide swaths of the globe: Latin America, Russia and Western Europe especially. Gardiner and the rest of the 'apology' critics ignore these facts, shouting that the tough Bush/Neocon foreign policy enhanced America's position in the world, when in reality it did the opposite.

There's certainly room to criticize Obama's foreign policy, but that criticism needs to be more than some lame charges that he's an apologist.
Sphere: Related Content

Wednesday, June 3, 2009

US, LA at odds again over Cuba

Cuba is once again dominating relations between the United States and Latin America.

The forum this time is the annual meeting of the Organization of American States. Cuba was kicked out of the OAS back in 1962 after the revolution that brought Fidel Castro to power. Now most of the members of the OAS think it's time for the ban to end, the one member that doesn't is of course the United States. The United States is saying that Cuba first would need to make democratic and human rights reforms before the US would back a Cuban membership bid.

So far this argument has taken up a day of the OAS meeting. And according to the BBC report, it's pointless - Cuba has said they have no intention of rejoining the OAS now even if invited. So in other words, the United States is picking a fight over an issue that, in reality, doesn't exist; and it's causing more friction between the United States and Latin America at a time when Secretary of State Hillary Clinton has been arguing about the need for the US to rebuild ties with our neighbors to the South.

The OAS could vote to extend the invitation to Cuba without the United States' support.
Sphere: Related Content

Israel tries to pass the buck on Palestine

Politicians in Israel's parliament, the Knesset, have come up with an idea on how to solve their Palestinian problem - ship ‘em all to Jordan.

That's the gist of a proposal put forward earlier this week that would name an official Palestinian homeland. The only problem is that the homeland would be Jordan (and no one asked the Jordanians what they thought of this idea before proposing it).

The proposal’s supporters argue that it just makes sense since more than half of the folks in Jordan can trace their roots back to Palestine. But critics say that the proposal is just a thinly-veiled attempt to expel all of the Palestinians from the West Bank, and the proposal has already caused an uproar in Jordan, putting more stress on an already strained relationship between the Israeli and Jordanian governments.

The proposal was put forward by the National Union party, which holds only four seats in the Knesset. Some are saying that the National Union only put the idea forward to cause problems for Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu because he didn't include their party in his governing coalition. Netanyahu slammed the Jordan proposal. But members of Jordan's parliament respond by pointing out that the proposal then received 53 votes in the 120-member Knesset, an indication, they say, of broader support for the idea.

Expect a lot more on this topic in the next few days as Barack Obama conducts his whirlwind tour of the Middle East.
Sphere: Related Content